Critical Comparison of Phase-Field, Peridynamics, and Crack Band Model M7 in Light of Gap Test and Classical Fracture Tests

Bazant Z. P., Nguyen H. T., Donmez A. A.

JOURNAL OF APPLIED MECHANICS-TRANSACTIONS OF THE ASME, vol.89, no.6, 2022 (SCI-Expanded) identifier identifier

  • Publication Type: Article / Article
  • Volume: 89 Issue: 6
  • Publication Date: 2022
  • Doi Number: 10.1115/1.4054221
  • Journal Indexes: Science Citation Index Expanded (SCI-EXPANDED), Scopus, Academic Search Premier, Aerospace Database, Applied Science & Technology Source, Communication Abstracts, Compendex, Computer & Applied Sciences, INSPEC, Metadex, zbMATH, DIALNET, Civil Engineering Abstracts
  • Keywords: computational mechanics, constitutive modeling of materials, model verification and validation, structural failure, fracture mechanics, boundary conditions, modes I, II, and III, size effect, quasibrittle materials, concrete, fracture tests, vertex effect, peridynamics, phase-field model, microplane model, SHEAR STRAIN-RATE, LOCAL KINETIC-ENERGY, VARIATIONAL APPROACH, IMPACT COMMINUTION, BRITTLE-FRACTURE, MICROPLANE MODEL, CONCRETE, STRENGTH, FAILURE, DAMAGE
  • Istanbul Technical University Affiliated: No


The recently conceived gap test and its simulation revealed that the fracture energy G(f) (or K-c, J(cr)) of concrete, plastic-hardening metals, composites, and probably most materials can change by +/- 100%, depending on the crack-parallel stresses sigma(xx), sigma(zz), and their history. Therefore, one must consider not only a finite length but also a finite width of the fracture process zone, along with its tensorial damage behavior. The data from this test, along with ten other classical tests important for fracture problems (nine on concrete, one on sandstone), are optimally fitted to evaluate the performance of the state-of-art phase-field, peridynamic, and crack band models. Thanks to its realistic boundary and crack face conditions as well as its tensorial nature, the crack band model, combined with the micro-plane damage constitutive law in its latest version M7, is found to fit all data well. On the contrary, the phase-field models perform poorly. Peridynamic models (both bond based and state based) perform even worse. The recent correction in the bond-associated deformation gradient helps to improve the predictions in some experiments, but not all. This confirms the previous strictly theoretical critique (JAM 2016), which showed that peridynamics of all kinds suffers from several conceptual faults: (1) It implies a lattice microstructure; (2) its particle-skipping interactions are a fiction; (4) it ignores shear-resisted particle rotations (which are what lends the lattice discrete particle model (LDPM) its superior performance); (3) its representation of the boundaries, especially the crack and fracture process zone faces, is physically unrealistic; and (5) it cannot reproduce the transitional size effect-a quintessential characteristic of quasibrittleness. The misleading practice of "verifying" a model with only one or two simple tests matchable by many different models, or showcasing an ad hoc improvement for one type of test while ignoring misfits of others, is pointed out. In closing, the ubiquity of crack parallel stresses in practical problems of concrete, shale, fiber composites, plastic-hardening metals, and materials on submicrometer scale is emphasized.